La Jolla Resort Islamorada: Retro Waterfront Escape
Contact Info
La Jolla Resort Islamorada is a charming, retro-inspired waterfront haven located in the “Sportfishing Capital of the World.” If you are planning a trip to the Florida Keys and want to skip the massive, cookie-cutter hotel chains in favor of an authentic, Old Florida experience, this colorful boutique motel delivers on all fronts. Situated perfectly on the bayside of the island, La Jolla Resort Islamorada offers an idyllic blend of vintage character and modern comfort. In this comprehensive informational guide, we will dive into everything you need to know about booking a stay here, including room options, complimentary amenities, and the best local attractions just minutes from the property.
Prime Bayside Location and Atmosphere
Location is everything in the Keys, and La Jolla Resort Islamorada boasts an enviable spot right at Mile Marker 82.3 on the Overseas Highway. Because it sits on the Florida Bay side (rather than the Atlantic Ocean side), guests are treated to some of the most spectacular, unobstructed sunset views in the entire island chain.
The atmosphere at La Jolla Resort Islamorada is famously laid-back and welcoming. The property features a vibrant, retro aesthetic with bright tropical colors, classic mid-century motel architecture, and lush, palm-tree-lined grounds. You won’t find loud pool parties here; instead, expect a serene environment where guests relax in hammocks under the swaying palms, read books by the water, and gather around the fire pits as the sun goes down.
Room Types and Accommodations
Whether you are traveling for a romantic couples weekend or a family vacation, La Jolla Resort Islamorada provides a variety of room layouts to suit your needs. The accommodations have been thoughtfully updated to ensure modern comfort while retaining their quirky, nostalgic charm.
-
Standard Guest Rooms: These cozy, well-appointed rooms are perfect for short stays. They typically feature king or queen beds, colorful tropical decor, flat-screen TVs, and mini-fridges to keep your drinks cold.
-
Kitchenette Suites: For those who prefer to cook or mix their own drinks, these suites are a fantastic upgrade. They offer additional living space and kitchenettes equipped with microwaves, larger refrigerators, and basic dishware, making them a very budget-friendly option.
-
Freestanding Cottages: If you want maximum privacy during your stay at La Jolla Resort Islamorada, opt for one of their standalone cottages. These units feel like your own private Keys bungalow, often featuring full kitchens and private porches where you can enjoy your morning coffee in the warm ocean breeze.
On-Site Amenities and Water Sports
One of the main reasons travelers consistently choose La Jolla Resort Islamorada is the incredible value provided by its on-site amenities. The resort makes it incredibly easy to enjoy the water without needing to book expensive external tours.
-
Private Beach and Pool: The property features a private, sandy bayside beach area lined with comfortable lounge chairs and tiki huts. Just steps away, there is a sparkling, heated outdoor swimming pool perfect for a refreshing dip after a day in the Florida sun.
-
Complimentary Water Toys: Guests have free access to paddleboards and kayaks. Launching right from the resort’s beach into the calm, shallow waters of the Florida Bay is a breeze, and it’s very common to spot manatees or dolphins cruising by the property.
-
Bicycles and Games: Want to explore the island on land? La Jolla Resort Islamorada provides complimentary bicycles for cruising up and down the paved Florida Keys Overseas Heritage Trail. On the property, you can also enjoy classic lawn games and waterfront fire pits in the evenings. Be sure to review our Florida Keys Packing List to make sure you have the right gear for all these outdoor activities.
Local Dining in Islamorada
While the resort itself is a tranquil retreat, you are just minutes away from some of the best seafood in the state. Islamorada is famous for its culinary scene, and staying here puts you right in the middle of it.
-
Walking Distance Options: You can easily walk or take a short bike ride to local favorites like Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar, which is legendary for its sunset celebrations, live music, and key lime coladas.
-
World-Class Seafood: Be sure to check out nearby iconic spots such as Chef Michael’s for incredibly fresh, locally caught fish, or Morada Bay Beach Cafe for dining with your toes in the sand. Don’t forget to read our Ultimate Islamorada Restaurant Guide for a full breakdown of the best waterfront places to eat.
Exploring Nearby Attractions
Basing your vacation at La Jolla Resort Islamorada means you are perfectly positioned to experience the best cultural and natural attractions the Middle and Upper Keys have to offer.
-
Robbie’s of Islamorada: Located just a few miles south, this famous marina is a must-visit. You can hand-feed massive tarpon right off the dock, browse local artisan stalls, and book snorkeling trips out to the reef.
-
History of Diving Museum: A fascinating, air-conditioned attraction nearby that chronicles humanity’s quest to explore under the sea—perfect for an afternoon break from the sun.
-
Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park: For a unique land-based excursion, explore this former quarry where the fossilized coral used to build the Overseas Railroad was mined. For current hours, trail maps, and entry fees, visit the official Florida State Parks website
Is La Jolla Resort Islamorada Right for You?
If you are seeking a massive luxury resort with bellhops and room service, this might not be your spot. However, if you are looking for a spotless, vibrant, and incredibly welcoming Old Florida motel with top-tier water access, La Jolla Resort Islamorada is an absolute gem. It provides an authentic, relaxing Keys experience that allows you to disconnect, unwind, and soak in the breathtaking bayside sunsets without breaking the bank. Booking a stay here means embracing the true, laid-back spirit of the islands.
Share
🗺️ This spot is on our interactive Florida map
We put 350+ of our local picks on one living map — the Vacation Florida Guide. The beaches without the crowds, the restaurants with no website, springs nobody knows about, where locals actually stay — and the famous spots worth skipping, with what to do instead.
- An interactive map on your phone — tap any pin for our honest local take.
- Ready-made itineraries — timed to beat the gates.
- New spots every week — buy once, updates for life.
It’s the guide we wish existed every time someone asked us “okay, but where would YOU go?”




