The Insider’s Key West Vacation Itinerary & Planner

Disclosure: This site contains affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission if you book through our links, at no extra cost to you.

Building Your Ultimate Key West Vacation Itinerary

Crafting the perfect Key West vacation itinerary is the secret to unlocking the very best of the southernmost point in the continental United States. Whether you are flying directly into EYW or taking the incredibly scenic drive down the Overseas Highway, arriving on the island is just the beginning. Key West has a totally unique, laid-back “Conch Republic” vibe, but because it is only a 4-mile-long island, knowing exactly where to go and what to book in advance is absolutely crucial to maximizing your trip.

👉 Planning to get in the water? See our picks for the best Key West snorkeling tours, including Dry Tortugas day trips.

While it is impossible to personally visit/stay at all these properties and attractions on your Key West vacation itinerary, I have fully vetted and researched the absolute best, highly-rated options so you don’t have to, looking for the highest rated reviews, best value, and most affordable options.

Use this hub page to plan your entire trip from top to bottom. Simply browse the vetted listings in each category below to build a flawless, stress-free island getaway.

Where to Stay in Key West

The foundation of any great Key West vacation itinerary is securing the perfect home base. The island is generally divided into two main areas: Old Town and New Town. Visiting in late October? Read my Key West Fantasy Fest guide first: hotels book up months ahead and the rules catch a lot of first-timers.

If you want to be in the center of the action, steps away from Duval Street, historic bars, and the famous Hemingway Home, you want to look for historic conch cottages or boutique inns in Old Town. Just know that space is tight, and parking is a premium. If you prefer larger resort-style amenities, expansive ocean views, and don’t mind renting a bike or taking a quick shuttle into the historic district, the properties in New Town or near Smathers Beach are fantastic options.

Browse my top-rated local stays below:

525 United St, Key West, FL 33040, USA

Share Key West Adults-Only Hotel Near Duval Street | The Southernmost Inn

902 Whitehead St, Key West, FL 33040, USA

Share Lighthouse Hotel Key West Historic Inn

725 White St. & Petronia, Key West, FL, 33040

Share Authors of Key West Guest House

6401 Maloney Avenue Key West, FL 33040

Share Boyd’s Campground Key West

3841 N Roosevelt Blvd, Key West, 33040, FL

Share Key West Marriott Beachside Hotel

Load More

Top Things to Do on the Island

You can make your Key West vacation itinerary as relaxing or as action-packed as you want. For history buffs, wandering through the Truman Little White House or the Key West Cemetery offers an incredible glimpse into the island’s quirky past.

However, getting out on the crystal-clear Gulf waters is an absolute must. Booking a sunset catamaran sail or a snorkeling excursion to the living coral reef will easily be the highlight of your trip. Don’t forget to wrap up your evenings at Mallory Square to experience the iconic sunset celebration, complete with local street performers and artisans.

Book your top-rated island adventures below:

907 Whitehead Street, Key West, FL 33040

Share Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum Key West

Sebago Watersports, 205 Elizabeth St, Key West, FL 33040

Share Sebago Key West Reef Snorkel Sail: Reviews, Prices & What to Expect

$68
241 Front St, Key West, FL 33040

Share Fury Key West Reef Snorkel Trip: Reviews, Prices & What to Expect

$61
7005 Shrimp Road Slip A34, Key West, FL 33040

Share Key West Snorkeling Western Sambo Reef Tours & Private Charters

6003 Peninsular Ave Ste #4, Key West, FL 33040, USA

Share Ultimate Dry Tortugas Boat Charter Tour

5675 5th Ave, Key West, FL 33040, USA

Share Paradise Rentals Key West: Ultimate Golf Cart Guide

Load More

Where to Eat and Drink

The culinary scene here is a massive part of the experience. From grabbing a slice of authentic, tart Key Lime pie to eating fresh pink shrimp pulled straight from the local waters, your tastebuds are in for a treat.

Start your morning with a strong Cuban coffee, spend the afternoon lounging and grabbing a bite at Dante’s Pool Bar & Restaurant, and end your night exploring the legendary nightlife along Duval Street.

Discover the best local eats and nightlife below:

951 Caroline St. Key West, FL 33040

Share Discover Dante’s Key West Pool Bar: A Tropical Oasis Awaits!

Insider Travel Tips & Hacks

To make sure your Key West vacation itinerary goes off without a hitch, you need to know how to navigate the island like a local. One of the biggest mistakes first-timers make is assuming they need to rent a car for their entire stay. Space is incredibly limited, and parking fees can eat into your travel budget quickly.

Instead, embrace the island culture! Renting a bicycle or a scooter is by far the best way to get around Old Town. Before you finalize your transportation plans, be sure to read my complete guide: Do you need a car in Key West? A Local’s Guide to Parking & Getting Around

For even more information on local events and island history during your stay, you can also check out the official Florida Keys tourism board.

Latest Key West Travel Guides & Tips

Want to dive deeper into specific local secrets? Check out my latest in-depth articles, reviews, and travel tips focused entirely on Key West below:

Scroll to Top