Hemingway’s Tavern Melbourne Review
Contact Info

Hemingway’s Tavern Melbourne is a spectacular epicurean adventure that brilliantly brings the laid-back, vibrant spirit of Key West right to the heart of Central Florida’s Space Coast. While it is impossible to personally dine at all these local establishments across the Melbourne area, I have fully vetted and researched the absolute best, highly-rated options so you don’t have to, looking for the highest rated reviews, best value, and most affordable options. Tucked away conveniently on West Hibiscus Boulevard, this beloved eatery is deeply inspired by the life, travels, and legendary writings of Nobel Prize-winning author Ernest Hemingway. Whether you are craving an authentic Cuban sandwich after a long day at the beach or looking for the perfect spot to enjoy craft cocktails before catching a movie at the nearby theater, Hemingway’s Tavern Melbourne delivers an unforgettable dining experience.
A Key West Escape in Central Florida
The moment you walk up to Hemingway’s Tavern Melbourne, you are instantly transported away from the bustling city streets and into a tropical, island-inspired oasis. Tucked behind beautiful, mossy oak trees, the restaurant features a design and atmosphere that heavily mimics the famous Mallory Square. The interior is wonderfully decorated with subtle nods to “Papa” Hemingway’s adventurous life, featuring rich wood tones, comfortable booths, and a lively, energetic dining room.
If the Florida weather is behaving, you absolutely must request a table on their massive outdoor patio. This open-air seating area is incredibly popular among locals, offering a relaxed, breezy environment where you can kick back, listen to tropical tunes, and completely unwind. Because it is located in the same shopping plaza as a major movie theater, Hemingway’s Tavern Melbourne has become the ultimate destination for the perfect dinner-and-a-movie date night.
Floribbean Flavors and Cuban Classics
The culinary team at Hemingway’s Tavern Melbourne takes immense pride in showcasing ambitious “Floribbean” flavors—a beautiful, mouth-watering fusion of traditional Florida seafood and bright Caribbean spices. To start your meal, the crispy Conch Fritters and the savory Tostones Shrimp are absolute crowd-pleasers.
When it comes to the main courses, the Signature Cuban Sandwich is legendary. It features tender, slow-roasted mojo pork, sweet ham, melted Swiss cheese, mustard, and pickles, all pressed perfectly on authentic Cuban bread. If you are in the mood for fresh seafood, the Snapper Hemingway and the flavorful Key West Bowl (topped with perfectly grilled shrimp) are highly recommended by regulars. For the land-lovers, the thick, juicy Bison Burger and the fall-off-the-bone ribs, served alongside a massive portion of golden truffle fries, are guaranteed to satisfy the heartiest of appetites.
Papa’s Cocktails and Weekend Brunch
Ernest Hemingway was famously known for sharing a good drink with his friends in the “Key West Mob,” and Hemingway’s Tavern Melbourne honors that legacy with a truly award-winning beverage program. The bar shakes up incredible, hand-crafted cocktails, including the Traditional Cuban Mojito, the tropical Hibiscus Margarita, and the dangerously delicious Painkiller.
If you are visiting on the weekend, you are in for a massive treat. Between 10:00 AM and 2:00 PM, Hemingway’s Tavern Melbourne serves up one of the most highly rated brunches in the county. Guests constantly rave about the decadent Coconut Rum French Toast and the savory Pulled Pork Eggs Benedict. No matter when you visit, you absolutely must save room for dessert. The tart, refreshing Key Lime Pie and the towering slice of made-from-scratch Carrot Cake are the perfect sweet finishes to your island-inspired feast.
Past Client Review Sentiments
Based on the reviews section from past clients, the overall sentiment for Hemingway’s Tavern Melbourne is overwhelmingly positive, currently holding a very strong 4.7-star rating out of over 1,800 reviews. Diners frequently praise the generous portion sizes, the reasonable prices, and the undeniably fun, tropical atmosphere. The quality and tenderness of the brisket, ribs, and Cuban sandwiches are mentioned time and time again.
The service is also a major highlight for this establishment. Guests frequently leave glowing remarks for specific servers and bartenders—such as Jason, Katlyn, Jeff, and Hailey—noting their friendly, accommodating, and deeply knowledgeable approach to the menu. On the slightly critical side, a few patrons mentioned that the main dining room can get quite loud during peak dinner hours, making the outdoor patio the better option for quiet conversation. A very small handful of reviewers also noted occasional delays in the kitchen or minor billing discrepancies, but the vast majority of travelers completely agree that the exceptional flavors and vibrant energy make it a must-visit local staple.
Explore the Space Coast
Finding an incredible, themed restaurant is just the beginning of your Space Coast adventure. Melbourne and the surrounding beach towns offer a massive variety of culinary delights, ranging from casual waterfront tiki bars to upscale seafood bistros. Taking the time to explore these unique local spots will elevate your Florida vacation from standard to absolutely extraordinary.
Explore more of our favorite Melbourne Florida dining spots here.
For a closer look at their menu, special events, and hours of operation, you can check out the official Hemingway’s Tavern TripAdvisor listing.
Share
🗺️ This spot is on our interactive Florida map
We put 350+ of our local picks on one living map — the Vacation Florida Guide. The beaches without the crowds, the restaurants with no website, springs nobody knows about, where locals actually stay — and the famous spots worth skipping, with what to do instead.
- An interactive map on your phone — tap any pin for our honest local take.
- Ready-made itineraries — timed to beat the gates.
- New spots every week — buy once, updates for life.
It’s the guide we wish existed every time someone asked us “okay, but where would YOU go?”
