La Nina Restaurant Marathon: Authentic Cuban Eats
Contact Info
If you are looking for the absolute best, authentic island flavor in the Middle Keys, La Nina Restaurant Marathon needs to be at the very top of your dining list. When you are making that beautiful drive down the Overseas Highway, it is so easy to get caught up looking at the flashy, expensive tourist traps. But if you want to eat where the locals eat, you have to keep your eyes peeled for this unassuming, incredible little spot right off the main road.
While it is impossible to personally visit and stay at all these La Nina Restaurant Marathon alternatives across the island chain, I have fully vetted and researched the absolute best, highly-rated options so you don’t have to, looking for the highest-rated reviews, best value, and most affordable options. And let me tell you, this place checks every single box for an unforgettable, budget-friendly meal.
The Ultimate “Hole in the Wall” Vibe
There is a saying in the food world that the best meals come from the most unassuming places, and La Nina Restaurant Marathon is the definition of a hidden gem. This is not a fancy, white-tablecloth establishment. The inside dining room is incredibly compact and cozy—about the size of a standard family room—which means it can fill up fast during the morning breakfast rush and the lunchtime peak.
If the inside is packed, don’t worry! They have a fantastic, spacious outdoor covered patio area out back equipped with cooling fans and classic picnic tables. It is the perfect, ultra-casual environment to relax in your flip-flops after a long morning out on the boat. Just keep an eye out for the friendly local chickens and roosters that like to roam around the parking lot—it just adds to that authentic, old-school Florida Keys charm!
What to Order at La Nina Restaurant Marathon
The menu at La Nina Restaurant Marathon is packed with massive portions of traditional, mouth-watering Cuban cuisine. If it is your first time visiting, you absolutely have to try their signature Cuban Sandwich. It is famously huge—easily enough for two people with average appetites to share—pressed to perfection with crispy bread, tender pork, and just the right amount of mustard and pickles.
If you are stopping by for dinner, the Ropa Vieja (shredded beef) and the rich, flavorful Oxtail are absolute standouts. Seafood lovers will also be thrilled; the fresh grouper and the shrimp in Creole sauce are highly recommended by locals and visitors alike. Every entrée comes with generous sides, so be sure to order the black beans, rice, and sweet plantains to complete the experience.
And whatever you do, you cannot leave La Nina Restaurant Marathon without ordering a traditional Cuban coffee. Whether you grab it at the counter first thing in the morning with a hot Spanish omelette or take it to-go after lunch, it is the perfect, sweet jolt of caffeine you need to fuel your island adventures.
Pricing, Value, and Local Pro-Tips
One of the biggest reasons La Nina Restaurant Marathon is so beloved is the incredible value. In a region where dining out can quickly break the bank, this spot offers massive, delicious portions at a fraction of the price of the big waterfront resorts. Many visitors report taking half their meal back to their hotel for lunch the next day.
Local Tip: If you want to elevate your lunch, order your Cuban sandwiches to-go and take a quick 10-minute drive down to Sombrero Beach. You can sit at the oceanfront picnic tables and enjoy your meal with a world-class view of the Atlantic!
When cashing out, just be aware of their transparent pricing policies: they automatically include a 15% gratuity on the bill, and there is a 3% fee if you choose to pay with a credit card. Even with these standard additions, the total value is completely unmatched in the Middle Keys. For more great dining options, check out this guide on dining in the Florida Keys.
Review Summary: What Past Clients Are Saying
The sentiment from past patrons of La Nina Restaurant Marathon is overwhelmingly positive, with visitors consistently praising the massive portion sizes and the authentic, homemade taste of the food. Reviewers frequently highlight the Cuban sandwich and the Cuban coffee as absolute must-try items. Guests appreciate the incredibly friendly, hardworking, and attentive staff who manage the busy counter with a smile. While some noted that the indoor seating is tight and the highway parking can be a bit tricky to navigate, the general consensus is that the incredible flavors and unbeatable prices make this casual diner a mandatory stop on any Middle Keys road trip.
Share
🗺️ This spot is on our interactive Florida map
We put 350+ of our local picks on one living map — the Vacation Florida Guide. The beaches without the crowds, the restaurants with no website, springs nobody knows about, where locals actually stay — and the famous spots worth skipping, with what to do instead.
- An interactive map on your phone — tap any pin for our honest local take.
- Ready-made itineraries — timed to beat the gates.
- New spots every week — buy once, updates for life.
It’s the guide we wish existed every time someone asked us “okay, but where would YOU go?”


